Lessons learned loading TIF images

Message Topic Search Topic Options Post Reply Create New Topic Printable Version Translate Topic

   All:

After some great help (thanks Marian!) learning the basics of converting TIF images to PDF documents, I discovered a few problems and tricks along the way that I will now share.  I'm working in VB6.

After initially getting over the hump of learning that you must not only use 

 QP.AddImageFromFile(tifFileName, 0)   but also  QP.DrawImage(left, top, width, height....)    as well  (image that...),  and discovering the right co-ordinate system, so that I acutally drew the image ON the page.... 

I found the images I was adding were not appearing correctly in the PDF document. 

I was adding TIF images, 8 bit color,  LZW compression.  They were appearing in the PDF as grey scale. The white background was black, the colors were various grey scale.  Yuuch!

I discovered that the TIF images had to be 24 bit color before they would appear correctly.  Problem Solved. Well, not really.  This lead to another problem.  

The AddImageFromFile() call was very slow!! The images I was using for testing was ~ 1000 x 1000 dots, 125 DPI, roughly one letter or A4 page. Nothing huge. 150k on disk.  The call was taking 5-10 seconds to complete!

8 bit files were much faster. under 1 second. But I could not use them due to the color issue

I even tried using variant arrays to initially store the image (my image handling control has this function), then use qp.AddImageFromVariant() in an attempt to speed up the call. It was actually slightly slower if anything....

So the trial and error continued.  I tried other formats. JPEG files (native 24bit) did not work at all, I would get errors opening the pdf'.s  "Insufficient data for an image" and the files were obviously too small (2k) suggesting correct conversion in the file). 

In the end, bitmap (bmp) files were the answer. The same image, as 24 bit BMP files, take under 1 second to load using AddImageFromFile()

Hope this helps someone in the future. After all the questions regarding image handling, I'm especially happy to have this working and to share what I have learned.

Cheers! 

Jim

Author	Message Topic Search Topic Options Post Reply Create New Topic Printable Version Translate Topic
JimCanuck Members Profile Find Members Posts Beginner Joined: 13 Aug 07 Location: Canada Status: Offline Points: 4	Post Options Post Reply Quote JimCanuck Report Post Thanks(0) Quote Reply Topic: Lessons learned loading TIF images Posted: 16 Aug 07 at 2:31PM
	All: After some great help (thanks Marian!) learning the basics of converting TIF images to PDF documents, I discovered a few problems and tricks along the way that I will now share. I'm working in VB6. After initially getting over the hump of learning that you must not only use QP.AddImageFromFile(tifFileName, 0) but also QP.DrawImage(left, top, width, height....) as well (image that...), and discovering the right co-ordinate system, so that I acutally drew the image ON the page.... I found the images I was adding were not appearing correctly in the PDF document. I was adding TIF images, 8 bit color, LZW compression. They were appearing in the PDF as grey scale. The white background was black, the colors were various grey scale. Yuuch! I discovered that the TIF images had to be 24 bit color before they would appear correctly. Problem Solved. Well, not really. This lead to another problem. The AddImageFromFile() call was very slow!! The images I was using for testing was ~ 1000 x 1000 dots, 125 DPI, roughly one letter or A4 page. Nothing huge. 150k on disk. The call was taking 5-10 seconds to complete! 8 bit files were much faster. under 1 second. But I could not use them due to the color issue I even tried using variant arrays to initially store the image (my image handling control has this function), then use qp.AddImageFromVariant() in an attempt to speed up the call. It was actually slightly slower if anything.... So the trial and error continued. I tried other formats. JPEG files (native 24bit) did not work at all, I would get errors opening the pdf'.s "Insufficient data for an image" and the files were obviously too small (2k) suggesting correct conversion in the file). In the end, bitmap (bmp) files were the answer. The same image, as 24 bit BMP files, take under 1 second to load using AddImageFromFile() Hope this helps someone in the future. After all the questions regarding image handling, I'm especially happy to have this working and to share what I have learned. Cheers! Jim

Ingo Members Profile Find Members Posts Moderator Group Joined: 29 Oct 05 Status: Offline Points: 3529	Post Options Post Reply Quote Ingo Report Post Thanks(0) Quote Reply Posted: 16 Aug 07 at 5:21PM
	Hi Jim! Thanks for your detailed help! Postings like yours are quite seldom here. Welcome and best regards, Ingo

Michel_K17 Members Profile Find Members Posts Newbie www.exp-systems.com Joined: 25 Jan 03 Status: Offline Points: 297	Post Options Post Reply Quote Michel_K17 Report Post Thanks(0) Quote Reply Posted: 25 Aug 07 at 10:10AM
	Wow... good info: thank you for sharing. Sounds like QuickPDF has a lot of image handling issues. I imagine then that the best bet is to use a separate image library in VB6 to import a TIF/JPG etc. , convert to BMP either in memory, or to a file, and then import into the PDF? What a shame.
	Michel

Francesco Members Profile Find Members Posts Beginner Joined: 26 Sep 07 Location: Italy Status: Offline Points: 4	Post Options Post Reply Quote Francesco Report Post Thanks(0) Quote Reply Posted: 29 Sep 07 at 8:38AM
	Is not a good idea to export TIF/JPG images as BMP and then import this in the PDF as in this case you will loose original compression ! For example, if you have a TIF file with an A4 bitonal page compressed as G4, and the files size is 50 Kb, if you will import directly from TIF then the PDF created will have about the same size, while if you export to BMP then the PDF created will be about 1000 Kb. Also if you enable the image compression, the file will be compressed using "deflate" algo (not G4) and the image will still be 200/300 kb... Francesco

StarSteve Members Profile Find Members Posts Beginner Joined: 07 Nov 05 Location: Germany Status: Offline Points: 6	Post Options Post Reply Quote StarSteve Report Post Thanks(0) Quote Reply Posted: 26 Nov 07 at 8:30PM
	Hi All, hmm... very strange this image (esp. TIF/JPEG) problems weren't in version 4.41.1.1 (21.12.2004), but indeed in version 5.22.0.145 (01.03.2007). Also, the SaveImageToFile doesn't work with TIF/JPEG (anymore) see sample (in v5.22 all corrupted, missing images are 24bit JPEG): v.4.41= NO PROB: http://astroworld.net/DEV/samples/v41.pdf v.5.22= BIG PROB: http://astroworld.net/DEV/samples/v52.pdf I guess, accidently something was changed in the code to no good Q2Proggers: any idea ? please solve, if possible... cu Stefan

StarSteve Members Profile Find Members Posts Beginner Joined: 07 Nov 05 Location: Germany Status: Offline Points: 6	Post Options Post Reply Quote StarSteve Report Post Thanks(0) Quote Reply Posted: 26 Nov 07 at 9:21PM
	some add.notes to the above : v4.41 (24.12.2004) = OK v4.42 (01.04.2005) = OK v5.13 (08.01.2006) = OK v5.14 (11.02.2006) = OK v5.20 RC1 (20.11.2006) = OK v5.20 RC2 (05.12.2006) = OK v5.21 (28.12.2006) = OK v5.22 (01.03.2007) = ERROR since the s.c for v5.22 wasn't published yet, I can't check/review it myself but Michel could you plz do cheers Stefan

Michel_K17 Members Profile Find Members Posts Newbie www.exp-systems.com Joined: 25 Jan 03 Status: Offline Points: 297	Post Options Post Reply Quote Michel_K17 Report Post Thanks(0) Quote Reply Posted: 27 Nov 07 at 12:28AM
	Sorry. v5.22 Source code is in the hands of Marian who authored the changes and he is not making it available. We have discussed this at length and part of the problem is that Marian cannot work on the library for free. Nonetheless, I do know that Marian is pretty flexible and willing to help. Try sending him an e-mail at support[at]quickpdf[dot]org. Maybe he will be able to take a look and perhaps fix. Cheers!
	Michel

StarSteve Members Profile Find Members Posts Beginner Joined: 07 Nov 05 Location: Germany Status: Offline Points: 6	Post Options Post Reply Quote StarSteve Report Post Thanks(0) Quote Reply Posted: 27 Nov 07 at 9:03AM
	thx mate :) I 'll do so asap - cheers Stefan